Skip to content

Running the business · 9 min read

Job costing for moving companies: how to know whether every move made money

How movers work out the true cost and profit of each job: labor, truck, materials, fees and overhead, with a worked example and a weekly routine.

By the MoveHelm team · Published

Job costing for moving companies: how to know whether every move made money: cover illustration

Key takeaways

  • Job costing means working out what each move actually cost you, so you can see which jobs, crews, salespeople and move types make money and which do not.
  • The biggest costs on a move are labor and the truck. Use clocked hours, real pay rates with payroll costs, and a per-hour truck cost, not guesses.
  • Compare each job's actual hours and costs with its estimate. The gap tells you whether the problem is pricing, estimating or how the move was run.
  • Review job costs every week while the details are fresh, then look for patterns monthly: move size, day of week, salesperson, crew and lead source.
  • You do not need perfect numbers to start. Consistent, slightly rough numbers on every job beat precise numbers on a few.

Most moving company owners know whether last year was a good year. Far fewer know whether last Tuesday's three-bedroom move made money. The bank balance and the year-end profit and loss tell you about the whole business, but they hide the details: the flat-rate job that ran four hours over, the long carry nobody priced, the crew that always finishes early, the move size you keep losing money on.

Job costing fixes that. It means working out the real cost of each move and comparing it with what you charged. This guide explains what to include, how to calculate each cost, how to read the results and how to build a simple weekly routine that fits a busy moving company.

For the bigger picture of margins across the whole business, see moving company profit margins. This guide zooms in on the single job.

What job costing tells you

When you know the profit of every job, you can answer questions that otherwise rely on gut feeling:

  • Are our flat rates priced right? Or are we winning flat-rate jobs because they are too cheap?
  • Which move sizes make money? Studios, three-bedrooms, offices, long-distance?
  • Which salespeople estimate accurately? And which ones keep under-quoting hours?
  • Which crews run efficient moves? And which ones need coaching?
  • Which lead sources bring profitable jobs? Not just booked jobs.
  • Are our minimums and travel charges covering the cost? Especially on small moves.

Without job costing, these questions are answered by whoever argues loudest. With it, you have numbers.

The costs of a single move

A move has direct costs, which you can tie to that job, and a share of overhead, which keeps the business running.

CostWhat it includesWhere to get the number
Crew laborHours worked by each mover, including travel time you pay forClock-in and clock-out records
Payroll costsEmployer payroll taxes, workers' comp, benefitsYour payroll provider and insurance policy, as a percentage of wages
TruckFuel, plus a per-hour or per-mile cost for payment, insurance, maintenance and tiresFuel receipts and your annual truck costs
MaterialsBoxes, tape, wrap, mattress bags, items you sell or useMaterials logged on the job
Third-party costsParking permits, tolls, equipment rental, subcontracted crews, disposal feesReceipts on the job
Payment feesCard processing feesYour payment provider statement
CommissionSales commission on the job, if you pay oneYour commission plan
Overhead shareOffice staff, rent, software, marketing, insurance, licensingAnnual overhead divided by job hours or jobs

The first seven are direct costs. Revenue minus direct costs is the job's gross profit. Take away the overhead share and you get an estimate of the job's net profit.

Labor: the biggest number

On most local moves, crew labor is the largest cost. Get it right first.

  • Use clocked hours, not estimated hours. The whole point is to compare reality with the estimate.
  • Include paid travel time. If you pay movers from the shop and back, that time belongs to the job, even if you charge customers a fixed travel fee.
  • Use each mover's actual rate. A crew lead earning more than a new mover changes the cost of the job.
  • Add payroll costs. Employer taxes, workers' comp and any benefits add a percentage on top of wages. Your payroll provider and insurance agent can tell you what that percentage is for your business.
  • Count overtime correctly. An overtime hour costs more than a regular hour, so a job that pushes a crew into overtime costs more than it looks.

See moving crew pay and tips for how pay structures affect your labor cost.

Truck: a cost per hour or per mile

Trucks cost money even when they are parked. To put a fair truck cost on each job:

  1. Add up the annual cost of each truck: payment or depreciation, insurance, registration, maintenance, tires and repairs.
  2. Divide by the hours or miles the truck works in a year. That gives you a cost per working hour or per mile.
  3. Add fuel for the job, either from receipts or from miles driven.

Local movers usually find a per-hour truck cost easier. Long-distance movers often use a per-mile cost. Either works if you use it consistently. See moving truck fleet utilization for how idle trucks raise your cost per hour.

Overhead: spread it fairly

Overhead is everything that is not tied to one job: office staff, rent, software, marketing, insurance, licenses, phones and the owner's salary. Two common ways to share it across jobs:

  • Per crew hour: annual overhead divided by total crew hours worked. Bigger, longer jobs carry more overhead.
  • Per job: annual overhead divided by number of jobs. Simpler, but small jobs carry the same overhead as big ones.

Per crew hour is usually fairer for movers, because big jobs really do use more office time, more scheduling and more truck days. Recalculate it a few times a year as your volume changes.

A worked example

Here is a local flat-rate move, with numbers invented for illustration. Use your own costs.

LineEstimateActual
Price charged$1,450$1,450
Crew hours (3 movers)18 hours (6 each)22.5 hours (7.5 each)
Labor at $22 per hour$396$495
Payroll costs at 20% of wages$79$99
Truck at $30 per hour, plus fuel$230$275
Materials$60$85
Parking permit$0$40
Card fee at 3%$44$44
Direct costs$809$1,038
Gross profit$641$412
Overhead at $12 per crew hour$216$270
Net profit$425$142

The job still made money, but much less than planned. The job cost tells you where it went: an extra 90 minutes per mover, more materials than estimated and a parking permit nobody quoted. Now you can ask the right questions. Was the inventory incomplete? Was there a long carry? Did the salesperson miss the parking situation?

Cardboard boxes on a tiled floor
Boxes on the floor: every box, hour and permit belongs on the job's cost sheet

Reading the results

One job tells you a story. Many jobs tell you a pattern. Group your job costs and look at averages:

Group byWhat you might find
Move sizeStudios lose money after travel; three-bedrooms are your sweet spot
Pricing methodFlat-rate jobs run over estimate more than hourly ones
SalespersonOne estimator consistently under-quotes hours
Crew leadOne crew finishes faster with fewer claims
Day of weekWeekend jobs carry overtime that the price does not cover
Lead sourceJobs from one source have lower margins after the lead cost
AreaJobs in one part of town take longer because of parking and access

Act on the pattern, not on one bad job. If studios keep losing money, raise the minimum or the travel charge. If one estimator keeps under-quoting, retrain them with the jobs that went over. If one lead source brings low-margin jobs, compare it again. See moving lead providers compared and moving company KPIs.

Estimate vs actual: the most useful comparison

Comparing estimated hours and costs with actual ones is the heart of job costing. When a job goes over, the cause is usually one of three things:

  1. Pricing: the estimate was right, but your rates or minimums do not cover your costs. Fix your rates. See hourly vs flat rate pricing for local moves.
  2. Estimating: the estimate missed something, such as items, stairs, a long carry or parking. Fix the survey. See video and virtual moving surveys and the moving inventory list guide.
  3. Execution: the estimate was right, but the move ran slowly, the crew was short or the truck was late. Fix dispatch and training. See the moving company dispatch guide.

Each cause needs a different fix. Without job costing, many owners simply raise prices, which fixes the first cause and hides the other two.

Long-distance jobs

Long-distance moves need a few extra lines:

  • Driver pay and per diem for the trip.
  • Fuel and tolls for the whole route.
  • Per-mile truck cost, including the empty miles back if there is no return load.
  • Hotel or sleeper costs if your drivers stay overnight.
  • Storage in transit, if used, including warehouse handling.

A long-distance job that looks profitable on the way out can lose money on the empty trip home. See pricing long-distance moves.

A simple weekly routine

Job costing only works if you do it regularly. A routine that fits most small and mid-size movers:

  1. Every day: make sure crews clock in and out, and that materials, permits and extra charges are recorded on each job before it is closed.
  2. Every week: review last week's completed jobs. Look at the ones that ran more than 15 to 20 percent over estimate and find the reason while everyone still remembers.
  3. Every month: group the month's jobs by move size, salesperson, crew and lead source. Look for patterns and decide on one or two changes.
  4. Every quarter: recalculate your overhead per crew hour and truck cost per hour, and check your rates against them.

Keep it simple. A short list of jobs with revenue, labor, materials and profit, reviewed every week, is worth more than a perfect spreadsheet nobody opens.

Common mistakes

  • Using estimated hours instead of clocked hours, which hides the very problem you are looking for.
  • Forgetting payroll costs, which makes labor look cheaper than it is.
  • Leaving out the truck, because it is "already paid for."
  • Ignoring small costs such as permits, tolls and card fees, which add up across hundreds of jobs.
  • Reacting to one bad job instead of looking for patterns.
  • Doing it once a year, when nobody remembers why a job went over.

Getting started this week

  1. Pick last week's completed jobs.
  2. For each one, write down the price, clocked crew hours, labor cost with payroll costs, truck cost, materials and other costs.
  3. Work out gross profit and margin for each job.
  4. Mark the three jobs with the lowest margin and find out why.
  5. Decide on one change to pricing, estimating or operations.
  6. Repeat next week.

You will learn more about your business in a month of job costing than in a year of looking only at the bank balance.

Frequently asked questions

What is job costing for a moving company?

Job costing means working out the actual cost of each move, including crew labor, payroll costs, truck, materials, permits, fees and a share of overhead, and comparing it with the price charged to see how much profit each job made.

How do you calculate labor cost on a move?

Multiply each mover's clocked hours, including any paid travel time, by their pay rate, count overtime at the overtime rate, and add employer payroll costs such as payroll taxes, workers' comp and benefits as a percentage of wages.

How should movers include truck costs in a job?

Add up each truck's annual costs, such as payment or depreciation, insurance, maintenance and tires, divide by the hours or miles it works in a year to get a cost per hour or per mile, and add fuel for the job.

How often should a moving company review job costs?

Review completed jobs weekly while the details are fresh, look for patterns by move size, salesperson, crew and lead source monthly, and recalculate overhead and truck costs every quarter.

Sources and further reading

This article is general information, not legal, tax or insurance advice. Rules change; check the source before you act.

Written by the MoveHelm team

We build MoveHelm, moving company software made side by side with a working Brooklyn mover. Our guides come from real jobs, real office days and the rules US movers work under. About us

Run your moving company in one place

Leads, estimates, dispatch, crews, texting, invoicing and reviews in one app. Try it free for 14 days, no card needed.